Two degrees of Warming May be "Prescription for Disaster "-James Hansen

Celsias

In December last year  James Hansen revealed that the two degrees of warming that many of us have hung our hat on for some time could actually be a prescription for disaster 

james hansen "The paleoclimate record reveals a more sensitive climate than thought, even as of a few years ago. Limiting human-caused warming to 2 degrees is not sufficient," Hansen said. "It would be a prescription for disaster."

The question he was seeking to answer in his newly released research was  the fundamental question of

"What is the dangerous level of global warming?"

Some international leaders have suggested a goal of limiting warming to 2 degrees Celsius from pre-industrial times in order to avert catastrophic change. But Hansen said at a press briefing at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco on Tues, Dec. 6, that warming of 2 degrees Celsius would lead to drastic changes, such as significant ice sheet loss in Greenland and Antarctica.

Based on Hansen's temperature analysis work at the Goddard Institute for Space Studies, the Earth's average global surface temperature has already risen .8 degrees Celsius since 1880, and is now warming at a rate of more than .1 degree Celsius every decade. This warming is largely driven by increased greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, particularly carbon dioxide, emitted by the burning of fossil fuels at power plants, in cars and in industry. At the current rate of fossil fuel burning, the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere will have doubled from pre-industrial times by the middle of this century. A doubling of carbon dioxide would cause an eventual warming of several degrees, Hansen said.



Hansen focused much of his new work  with co-author Makiko Sato , also of the Goddard Institute on how the polar regions and in particular the ice sheets of Antarctica and Greenland will react to a warming world. 

arctic ice melt Two degrees Celsius of warming would make Earth much warmer than during the Eemian, and would move Earth closer to Pliocene-like conditions, when sea level was in the range of 25 meters higher than today, Hansen said. In using Earth's climate history to learn more about the level of sensitivity that governs our planet's response to warming today, Hansen said the paleoclimate record suggests that every degree Celsius of global temperature rise will ultimately equate to 20 meters of sea level rise. However, that sea level increase due to ice sheet loss would be expected to occur over centuries, and large uncertainties remain in predicting how that ice loss would unfold.

Hansen notes that ice sheet disintegration will not be a linear process. This non-linear deterioration has already been seen in vulnerable places such as Pine Island Glacier in West Antarctica, where the rate of ice mass loss has continued accelerating over the past decade. Data from NASA's Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite is already consistent with a rate of ice sheet mass loss in Greenland and West Antarctica that doubles every ten years. The GRACE record is too short to confirm this with great certainty; however, the trend in the past few years does not rule it out, Hansen said. This continued rate of ice loss could cause multiple meters of sea level rise by 2100, Hansen said.

pine island glacier

"We don’t have a substantial cushion between today's climate and dangerous warming," Hansen said. "Earth is poised to experience strong amplifying feedbacks in response to moderate additional global warming." 

 This research is consistent with Hansen's earlier findings that carbon dioxide in the atmosphere would need to be rolled back from about 390 parts per million in the atmosphere today to 350 parts per million in order to stabilize the climate in the long term.  

Hansen and others noted that while the paleoclimate evidence paints a clear picture of what Earth's earlier climate looked like, but that using it to predict precisely how the climate might change on much smaller timescales in response to human-induced rather than natural climate change remains difficult. But, Hansen noted, the Earth system is already showing signs of responding, even in the cases of "slow feedbacks" such as ice sheet changes.



"Humans have overwhelmed the natural, slow changes that occur on geologic timescales," Hansen said.

 

3 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

Brian N. 10°

Very interesting and absolutely terrifying

Written in January

xtropy (anonymous)

A frustrating, incomplete, article. What are the action steps forward towards a positive resolution ? A changeover to IFR, or Stage 4, Nuclear power ? Integral Fast Reactors (IFR) use 99% of nuclear fuel, and uses nuclear waste as fuel. Current, Stage 2, Light Water Reactors, use only 1% of the fuel... leaving 99% as 'waste' ! Baseload & Footprint. Solar & Wind would take up a landmass larger than Australia as its footprint to handle the world's baseload energy demand. So no go there. No space. Stage 4 Nuclear would have a footprint the size of Rhode Island... for the whole planet's energy generation ! That's doable. Also... what about the ice caps on Mars. They're melting right ? Is that because the Sun is in a 'hotter phase' that Russian scientists call 'Solar Irradiance' ? And if so... wouldn't 'Solar Irradiance' melt the Earth's Ice caps as well ? This article fell FAR SHORT of addressing this issue in a creditable way. Good luck with your future articles.

Written in January

Kiwiiano (anonymous)

Odd tho it may seem, xtropy, it did occur to the scientific community that the rising atmospheric & oceanic temperatures might be caused by a hotter sun, but if anything it has been quieter of late.
Re your glooming about meeting impossible baseloads, perhaps we could throw some effort into reducing the baseloads. For example, we could reduce the size of vehicles. We only NEED about 50cc of engine capacity for 100kg of load. Anything more is habit or vanity. There are 1000's of similar ways to change our profligate ways. We'll either do it voluntarily or have it forced upon us.

Written in January

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • Posted on Jan. 6, 2012. Listed in:

    3 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Volunteering with BTCV, 27°

    Volunteering with BTCV is great for your body, your mind AND the environment. BTCV offers ...

    MINUS ONE - REDUCE THE FONT SIZE BY 1 BEFORE PRINTING. SAVE PAPER. HELP THE FORESTS., 11°

    The world bodies, like UN, WWF, Greenpeace are trying their best to save forests. But ...

    Follow Celsias on Twitter!, 291°

    Subscribe to Celsias Twitter posts and get direct updates of Celsias Articles, thoughts, new actions ...

    Follow these related projects

    Earth Hour US

    United States

    Featured Companies & Orgs