The Most Destructive Project on Earth: Alberta's Tar Sands

With oil prices over $100 a barrel this week, the companies involved in Canada's tar sands must be rubbing their hands in glee. The $26 a barrel cost of processing (compared to about $1 in Saudi Arabia) suddenly doesn't look so bad. Oil companies who have chosen not to invest may be tempted to reconsider, and that's very bad news.

The Athabasca tar sands, in Alberta, may be the world's largest oil reserve. Only the surface sands are accessible at the moment, but if the technology develops a little more, there's potentially six times more oil there than the whole of Saudi Arabia - enough to last 200 years, say the champions of the project.

But, it's not liquid oil, and extracting the crude from the sand takes vast reserves of water, a quarter of Alberta's fresh water. This water is so polluted at the end of the process that it is simply left to stand in huge tailing pools that altogether cover some 50 square kilometres. It's so toxic that birds landing on the ponds would die. Some places use propane cannons to scare the ducks away; others just rake the dead birds off the surface. As the ponds aren't lined, waste water leaks into the Athabasca River, polluting everything downstream - lakes, deltas, and the Mackenzie River.

It also destroys the land. Huge areas of the boreal forest ecosystem have been felled and the underlying peat bogs cleared away to expose the sands. At the end of the processing there is nothing but a 'toxic moonscape' of earthworks, ponds, and 80 foot high piles of pure sulphur. 5,000 hectares have been destroyed already, and David Schindler of the University of Alberta estimates that in ten years time they will have cleared an area the size of Florida.

The air is not spared either. It takes enormous amounts of heat to extract the oil, approximately a barrel of gas for every two of crude. The total emissions of the tar sands project will soon be equivalent to the whole of Denmark. Acid rain falls all across Alberta and now Saskatchewan too. In the summer, the tailing ponds release carcinogenic benzene. "If the wind is from the north-west," writes Aida Edemariam of the nearby boomtown of Fort McMurray, "you can smell oil on the air: heavy, slightly sour, unmistakable."

All of this makes the tar sands 'the most destructive project on earth' (pdf), according to last week's report by Environmental Defence.

Having read last week that the site was visible from space, I tracked it down on Google. It's right here if you want to explore it and see for yourself.

4 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

You Are Stupid (anonymous)

As Above - You are not an ecologist ; but a liberal enviromentalist with your own agenda. People like you come and go just like the seasons.

Written in June 2011

Person above is stupid (anonymous)

How cute, an idiot who thinks he knows what he's talking about posted above me. Pretending this project won't cause immeasurable environmental damage is idiotic, as are you. This isn't about liberalism or your stupid political parties that you morons are so obsessed with. This is about a serious possible threat to the environment from this project. This isn't the place for whiny little brats who have to jam their politics into everything. Go die in a ditch.

Written in September 2011

jon (anonymous)

Thanks for the google map link. It puts in perspective just how small and insignificant this project is in comparison to the size of the earth. A brilliant discovery and use of natural resources to provide much needed energy to Americans, improving our quality of life.

Written in November 2011

The Monk (anonymous)

Hey Jon - hewman's like you - were named because all you know how to do is hew wood - also named man because all you know is how to manipulate. You are below the chimpanzee, when it comes to brains. The volume of the Earth below about ~oh~ 24 inches below the surface is completely unusable to human life. Only the surface is. And the amount of water on the surface, is a tiny amount. Tiny. When the water runs out, and there are no forests left to like, create air, the day you are choking on your last dying breath, try not to be thinking of me.

The Monk

Written in May 2012

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • Posted on March 4, 2008. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Jeremy »

    4 comments

    Pledge to do these related actions

    Choose natural products for your garden, 298°

    Reduce the amount of fertilizer and pesticide going into water tables and natural environments by ...

    Give Coal The Boot, 61°

    Greenpeace are asking people to help give coal the boot once and for all: "Burning ...

    Stop Misleading Energy Pipedreams with your signature!, 1°

    Please sign my petition "Stop Misleading Energy Pipedreams." Remind Congress that we don’t want to ...

    Follow these related projects

    CO2 - Ionic Exchange for Climate Change - CO2 Converter

    San Carlos de Bariloche, Rio Negro, Argentina

    Featured Companies & Orgs