Naughty Non-Profits: 7 Eco-Sins

Raegan Payne

I am about to do something slightly ungrateful, definitely heinous, very uncomfortable, but in the end completely necessary: I'm going to blow the environmental whistle (or horn) on many of the non-profits I've been helping this year.  Let me explain why - I've been trying to complete 50 different volunteer activities before 2010, which means I have volunteered with a lot of different non-profits in the last few months and unfortunately I have seen disappointing environmental practices at many of them.

Don't misunderstand me, charities do amazing work and help the world in a myriad of ways, but they are under funded, overwhelmed, and under staffed. As some non-profits try to wade through the muck of daily operations their environmental impact is overlooked.  Regrettably, because of this neglect they waste money, lose relevance, and in some extreme cases possibly lose volunteers and supporters.  I am not going to list names, but I am going to list some very real and very disappointing transgressions against the earth that I have witnessed in my volunteer work so far.

bleach 1)      The notorious bleach dumping episode.

One sunny morning I arrived at an inner city school to help a certain organization clean up classrooms. Things started going downhill when they pulled out jugs of bleach instead of hydrogen peroxide or distilled vinegar to clean the toys.  I reached the end of my rope when I saw organizers and volunteers dumping the used bleach into street gutters instead of a sink or toilet.  FYI this happened in Los Angeles, CA were the gutter system is unfiltered and dumps directly into the ocean.  When I confronted some of the dumpers and tried to educate them about the environment danger a teacher in charge yelled at me about wasting time. Gallons of bleach ended up floating to the sea that day.  Here's the lesson: toxic chemicals are just that, TOXIC, and if you feel the need to use them in mass please educate yourself and your staff on how to dispose of them properly. 

2)      Stop snail mailing me!

junk mailThis year I made a small donation in a family members name to one of the largest tree planting charities as a gift. Two months after the donation I started receiving letters requesting donations as did that family member.

Besides the fact that I now look like a twat for getting my relative on a junk mail list this organization used the money I gave them to plant trees to kill trees! Oh, the irony. The worst part is they are not the only organization that rewards generosity with junk mail. So right now I am on my knees begging as I type this line - Please, please, please charities everywhere stop snail mailing people it's wasteful and pisses us off. Thank you.

 3)      Recycling 101

Some groups still need to learn how basic recycling works.  In fact, the amount recyclables some non-profits carelessly throw away could be worth a hefty amount of cash. Animal shelters are a good example they use hundreds of cans of dog and cat food everyday to feed puppies, kittens, and sick animals.  In most of the animal shelters I've been in these steel and aluminum cans are tossed in the trash. I've seen huge piles of cans that must have weighed close to 50 pounds destined for a landfill.  Other non-profits still aren't recycling office paper, cardboard boxes, or even plastic water bottles and soda cans. I welcome these groups to join us in the 21st Century and help us all conserve resources by recycling.paintbrush

4)      Wash that off and use it again.

You would assume that non-profits who work in renovation and building projects all year long would reuse supplies like paintbrushes, paint trays, rags, and unused hardware.  The shocker is some groups don't. Instead they treat valuable construction supplies like Dixie cups. I understand that storage is tight, but if you paint another house next week or repair a fence you might need this stuff again.  Or perhaps you should offer all gently used tools to the homeowner you just helped because it appears they lack the funds to buy this equipment themselves. Throwing out a paintbrush or tool that is used only once is unacceptable. 

5)      No one wants those t-shirts. They don't even fit.

The hideous charity shirt, emblazoned with the groups seal, made of the cheapest and least flattering cotton, always available in M, L or XL never S or XS, no human should be forced to wear such an ill fitting garment.  At least half of the charities I have worked for hand these t-shirts out like mints.  Some of the groups won't let you refuse these ghastly tarps because they use them as a way to identify you as a volunteer while you work on their project.  These shirts are as wasteful as they are ugly.  The madness needs to stop. Charities, this is an intervention: No one wants your t-shirts.  They waste your money. They are made of cotton, which needed thousands of pounds of pesticides and fertilizers to grow.  Save your money and instead do more good works.  If you must give us something let it be a delicious cookie.

6)      Also no one wants throwaway nick knacks.  Same as the number 5 - if I volunteer for your charity you do not have to thank me with plastic bracelets, key chains, figurines, bookmarks, pens, balloons, magnets, hats, or patches (I am not a girl scout).  Save it, save the money, give me an apple or aforementioned delicious cookie.

7)      We have to find a solution for the plastic bags!  But I am at a loss as well.  Okay this one is tough.  Some non-profits use plastic bags to hand out meals or other necessities to people they may never see again. They can't hand out reusable bags because that will get expensive when the bags are not returned. Any ideas? 

None of us are environmental saints.  We all make mistakes. I hope that if any charitable organization comes across this blog they will understand that it was written out of love and the hope that by examining your daily operations you might find ways to save money, be earth friendly and operate more efficiently.

Other cool stuff on Celsias:

What Costs More Than Gas, Is Possibly Polluted, and Puts Chemicals in Your Kids?
How Many Lightbulbs Does it Take to Change a Human?

Follow us on Twitter: Celsiastweets

12 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

nice one Raegan! though i'm a little bemused by your comments about dumping bleaches - it doesn't matter which drain you put em down, they'll still pollute something somewhere; and in many places stormwater and sewage lines are inter-connected. better not to use toxics in the first place.

Written in June 2009

Very good point. I'm with you - best to just completely avoid toxics.

Written in June 2009

Charles M. 105°

This is really just a result of different people having different priorities. It is hard to sometimes accept that people that share some of your values don't share other values. Whether it is environmental issues, political party afficliations, smoking etc you're always going to disagree on some point.

On top of that a lot of volunteer organisations seem to be run by drill sergeants that didn't make the cut for the army. They're the ones wanting the shirts so their troops have a uniform and the badges etc as "medals". Unless you start your own organisations, these are the people that make things happen.

Don't fret the plastic bags. They are such a small part of the environmental footprint of what you're doing. Unless the meal you are handing out only contains fresh fruit and vegetables there is far more environmental footprint in the stuff in the bag than the bag itself.

As for the bleach debate, the active stuff in bleach gets triggered by reacting with dirt (which is why we use the stuff and it is so effective). After activation the stuff that is left is pretty benign (similar to table salt). Household bleach is very low concentration (5% or so). Bleach solutions will be activated (ie neutralised) quite quickly when poured down any drain/sewer.

Of course dumping large amounts (hundreds of gallons) or very concentrated sodium hypochlorite (the active stuff in bleach) is quite another matter.

Written in June 2009

Sabrina (anonymous)

I just wanted to mention that teachers LOVE those t-shirts. They use them with their kids for painting and arts & crafts - the fact that they're huge is useful to cover clothes.
If there was more organization of getting those shirts donated to schools for art-use... But as far as ugly and always way too big goes - yes, yes yes! And I'm all for delicious cookies.

Written in June 2009

Mackenzie (anonymous)

I'm with you on a lot of those things, though certainly if I were to gripe about non-profits I'd have bigger beefs than these. (Like misuse of funds, false advertising, not utilizing volunteers as well as they could... the list goes on and on.)

But to address the points you made... as far as plastic bags go, they can at least be reused. You can't guarantee that the people you're delivering goods to in the bags will reuse or recycle them, but the non-profit can re-use by asking people to donate their used supermarket plastic bags, so that the non-profit isn't paying to buy bags and isn't contributing additional bags to the landfill. A number of my local thrift stores do this rather than buying plastic bags for shopper purchases.

Also, direct mail IS totally annoying -- and in the case you cited, particularly ironic -- but you have to remember that for a lot of orgs that junk mail? Is the only reason they exist. I used to work for an animal rescue non-profit that was particularly incompetent when it came to figuring out how to raise funds when they started, but once they hooked up with a direct-mail company and started fundraising with those appeal letters? They started getting in enough cash to expand, buy land, establish a second sanctuary facility, pay huge veterinary bills, etc etc. So though some of us find it annoying, it's an incredibly effective fundraising tool.

And one last note on what you mentioned about knick-knacks. The aforementioned rescue used to occasionally give us volunteers and employees little gifts of appreciation. Usually these were ordered because the president of the org wanted one for herself or thought it was fun to get to order things. No joke. But for that reason some of those gifts became kicks in the teeth rather than gifts of appreciation. For instance, they ordered logo jackets one year for employees, which was awesome, but had only been concerned with ordering accurate sizes for themselves; they snapped up the two mediums and left the rest of us swimming in XXLs and other sizes so big we were swimming in them. A few years before that, they gave out little plaques for their regular volunteers... and spelled my name wrong. Personally, I'd rather have no gift at all than have a gift that shows that kind of lack of consideration. (I volunteered and later was employed at that place for about four years. The president, whom I worked with very closely on a number of projects and whom I emailed with information practically daily, has never spelled my last name correctly. And it's REALLY not a tough name.)

Written in June 2009

bleach-fan (anonymous)

You only need a small amount of bleach to disinfect. One tablespoon per gallon of water would pretty much kill any microbial baby slobber.

Written in June 2009

Travis (anonymous)

HEY CHARITIES.
I do want those tshirts. XL only please, I need them to build my hot air balloon. And could they be washed first? I hate it when the shirts make me itch. No bleach please.

Written in June 2009

Lorie (anonymous)

Hey Raegan...you make so many great points! Are ou sure you are a twat, though? I was thinking maybe twit! Haha! You make me smile!

Written in June 2009

Sally Jackson (anonymous)

Great stuff, Raegan. It's cool that you are on this volunteer thing and look where it's leading you! Interesting.
LovinYouFromAustin and Buddy says meow...
Sally

Written in June 2009

Brian (anonymous)

Hey - be careful you aren't interpreting things incorrectly. Often times, like in the case of the paint brushes, it can be other groups or other volunteers that are doing the throwing away, not necessarily the charity...

Written in July 2009

Hey Brian - Good point, sometimes it is the volunteers or a guest group that acts carelessly. Unfortunately, in the specific case I am referencing here I actually went up to the head of the charity and asked her specifically what to do with the equipment and she said toss it. Then (I must have been really annoying) I kept asking her the same question for every item I used - unfortunately every answer was "throw away." There was also a lot of demolition with this project and no recycling. I think the problem is sometimes we all just think of the task at hand and not the bigger picture. I know I do occasionally. I think it's a good idea just to step back every once and a while and ask, "What can I do better." So whether you're a volunteer (like me) or a big non-profit you can always be more mindful and do something more efficiently.

Written in July 2009

Vickie (anonymous)

Hey Raegan, there is a site called darngoodyarn with a video called '80 ways to save the planet'. She shows you how to knit a bag using 80 plastic bags! Very cool.. I have made 4 so far.. Also, Meijer stores take clean plastic bags in the front of their stores...

Written in October 2009

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • (hint: logged in Celsias members don't have to fill in this)
  • Posted on June 4, 2009. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Raegan »

    12 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Join a local food co-op, 133°

    Join with your community and support locally owned and operated food co-ops. Go Co-op!

    Ask The Climate Question, 1°

    Join and promote the campaign to raise climate change on the UK political agenda over ...

    Choose natural products for your garden, 252°

    Reduce the amount of fertilizer and pesticide going into water tables and natural environments by ...

    Follow these related projects

    The Homestead

    West Central Wisconsin, United States

    Media information on line

    Melbourne, Australia

    Featured Companies & Orgs