The Meat of Climate Change

Alina Beloussova

Militant vegan groups have been at it for years, pleaded the public to step away from the steak and embrace the veg. Environmentalists, on the other hand, have mostly shied away from such appeals. It wasn't until last January that Rajendra Pachauri, head of the IPCC, begged the world to "please eat less meat", acknowledging IPCC's former apprehension to make such a request: "This is something that the IPCC was afraid to say earlier, but now we have said it."

As the role of livestock production in global warming comes under scrutiny, the western meat eating habit is increasingly recognized as part of the problem. Even Mark Bittman, New York Times food columnist and a "meat-first" kind of guy began questioning our meat-guzzling ways and handing out tips for cutting back. He even published a vegetarian cookbook.

meatRegardless of such pleas, the average person in the developed world consumes around 225g (o.5lb) of meat per day. In the developing world, that figure goes down to 47g. However, global demand for meat is set to double by 2050 from the current 284 million tons, largely fueled by raising affluence in large developing countries like China, India and Brazil. These rampant rates of consumption are not without consequences.

Worldwide, livestock production is responsible for 18% of greenhouse gas emissions, more than all forms of transportation combined. Livestock occupies 30% of the worlds land surface, a large part of which is used for feedcrops such as corn and soy, plays a major part in deforestation, land degradation, water and fertilizer use and water pollution.

Searching for Solutions


On the one hand, technology can address part of the livestock emissions problem. In the Netherlands, for example, a pilot manure digestion project converts the methane from the waste of 3,000 pigs into electricity. The process reduces the farm's emissions, produces quality fertilizer and enough carbon credits to sell on European carbon markets.

In Denmark, it is now mandatory to inject manure underground rather than laying it on top of the fields, thus enhancing the fertilizing effect and prevents emissions from escaping. Elsewhere, scientists are attempting to produce feed that makes cows belch less methane. Not to mention the development of in vitro meat, made from cell cultures grown into tissue, which is apparently endorsed by PETA.

Regardless of what technological fixes we can find, the present trends of livestock production and consumption are simply unsustainable. Producing one pound of meat causes the emissions equivalent of 22 pounds of carbon dioxide, 11 times as much greenhouse gas emission as a pound of chicken and 100 times more than a pound of  carrots. And although a vegan diet typically emits 1.5 tons of CO2 per year less than the average American diet, it should be kept in mind that the production method matters, even in the case of vegetables.

Greenhouse grown tomatoes, for example, generate more emissions than the same amount of chicken. Beyond the same old educating, bargaining and pleading, proposals to curb demand range from adding a “sin tax” on pork and beef and emissions labeling (as Sweden plans to implement next year).

However, sin taxes and labeling would be unnecessary if the price of a steak would simply take into account all the environmental costs of producing, rather than the subsidies injected into the agro-industrial complex and lax environmental regulations. Correcting these imbalances might even give sustainable ways of production a fighting chance.

Related Reading:
Warmed by What We Eat
Why Eating a Big Mac is Cheaper Than Eating a Salad

Image Credit:
JC Westbrook

2 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

Dimitri F. 100°

please enjoy this video as a supplemental piece of information:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1308977765978236346

Written in December 2008

Charles M. 110°

Glad to see someone writing about this.

There is no global food shortage, there is is a problem with global food wastage. There is no problem with food production, rather the agricultural sector has a problem getting people to consume everything they generate.

To get the level of consumption up, we end up with very wasteful practices such as feedlot meat raising which takes 15-50 food units input (corn etc) and generates 1 food unit of meat output. Chicken and similar have the lowest conversion ratio (15:1). Beef has the worst (closest to 50:1), with pork etc somewhere in the middle.

Cleaning up the direct animal emissions is only cleaning up a small part of the problem. Mosty of the impact of raising meat occurs in generating the input feed - before it is eaten by the animals.

The article does not mention dairy which is just as bad as feedlot raised meat.

The impacts of a meat diet are worse if the meat is raised in feedlots.

Free range grass fed meat is far less damaging as it works in marginal lands and does not need ploughing up the land. Done effectively rasing animals this way is sustainable and even improves the soild quality.

Traditionally, animals have been part of a sustainable agricultural model:
* Running ducks in rice paddies to clean up pests and provide meat and eggs.
* Running chickens in orchards to clean up pests and dropped fruit and provide eggs and meat.
* Feeding chickens and pigs on food scraps.
* Running sheep as part of a pasture rotation to help revitalise the land.

This breaks down with the move to monocultures and feedlot production.

Written in December 2008

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • (hint: logged in Celsias members don't have to fill in this)
  • Posted on Dec. 23, 2008. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Alina »

    2 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Install a programmable thermostat, 361°

    Let the computer do the thinking for you by programming it to lower your house ...

    Population Pledge, 12°

    I pledge to have no more children other than via adoption. This will save a ...

    I heart clean energy, 11°

    This Valentines day, show your leaders in Washington why you care about a clean energy ...

    Follow these related projects

    Change the World for Fifteen Bucks

    NZ, Australia and the UK, United Kingdom

    Featured Companies & Orgs