Making the Environment Real

Brian Gordon

globeHaving just come through an election in Canada in which I was a Green Party candidate, and in which the anti-science, anti-environment Conservative government was re-elected, gave me cause to wonder what happened to my pro-environment Canadians. "The environment" was the #1 concern of Canadians not so long ago - before "the economy" trumped it.

So why didn't Canadians vote Green - not a single Green Member of Parliament was elected, again - or at least green: the major opposition to the Conservatives, the Liberals, proposed a "Green Shift (stolen from the Green Party and watered down), in which income tax would be replaced by a carbon tax. The Liberals and their Green Shift went down in flames, the victim of weak leadership and Conservative phony propaganda.

The answer, I believe, is that "the environment" is simply not real to most people. It is an abstract concept, and people cannot get motivated by abstract concepts unless they are somehow made to feel real.

The economy is also an abstract concept, but one's job and bills and financial security are most certainly real, so it's much easier to care about "the economy" - which ultimately trumped "the environment" and motivated many Canadians to vote Conservative.

The thing is, it doesn't get much more real than the environment. We are literally part of the environment and it is part of us. From ashes to ashes, dust to dust. No environment means no economy, no civilisation, even no humans if it changes enough. A few people do get this; the abstractness of the environment has become real to them. But to the majority, "the environment" is an optional ‘nice-to-have' that we take for granted, that we assume will always be there for us, that we will pay more attention to when there is more time, more money, more imminent danger.

As goes the environment, so goes humanity, so how do those of us who do ‘get it' make the environment real to people in the same way that the economy is, or family, or love? Because unless and until that happens, people will continue to focus on things more real to them, "the environment" will continue to deteriorate, and very soon it will be too late.

There are many answers to this, ranging from school vegetable gardens to presentations like The Inconvenient Truth. But the real bottleneck right now is political. Obama is a huge step in the right direction, because the President-Elect of the United States is talking about the seriousness of climate change and the desirability of green jobs. When powerful people talk, the majority listens, and Obama has more power than most. Even better, there is a cumulative effect, as Obama is now reinforcing what Al Gore has been saying. Suddenly, two very influential people are talking about the environment, and this legitimizes many lesser lights...and so the shift begins.

The key, I believe, will be in how we talk about climate change. If we continue to focus on doom-and-gloom scenarios, if we continue to try and scare people into going green, we will fail - just as environmentalists have largely failed for 30 years at attempts to shame people into going green.

Without vision, the people shall perish. Shame or fear-based appeals may scare us away from something...but toward what? We need a vision that draws us forward to a better future. We greens need to show people the way. Yes, we are facing a climate crisis, but it's a slow-motion disaster, and humans respond much better to immediate threats - or to powerful visions of a better, more secure, more prosperous, more responsible future.

That's what's lacking, though the void is starting to be filled by progressives like Al Gore and Barack Obama. From Gore:

...if we grab hold of that common thread and pull it hard, all of these complex problems begin to unravel and we will find that we're holding the answer to all of them right in our hand.

The answer is to end our reliance on carbon-based fuels.

In my search for genuinely effective answers to the climate crisis, I have held a series of "solutions summits" with engineers, scientists, and CEOs. In those discussions, one thing has become abundantly clear: when you connect the dots, it turns out that the real solutions to the climate crisis are the very same measures needed to renew our economy and escape the trap of ever-rising energy prices.

From Obama:

Climate change and our dependence on foreign oil, if left unaddressed, will continue to weaken our economy and threaten our national security.

My presidency will mark a new chapter in America's leadership on climate change that will strengthen our security and create millions of new jobs in the process.

This investment will not only help us reduce our dependence on foreign oil, making the United States more secure. And it will not only help us bring about a clean energy future, saving our planet. It will also help us transform our industries and steer our country out of this economic crisis by generating five million new green jobs that pay well and can't be outsourced.

Both messages communicate the problems and dangers - and offer plausible and even inspiring solutions. They offer a vision of a better future. That is what is missing. People need something concrete to make both the scope of the crisis - and the way out of it - real.

Without vision, the people shall perish.

2 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

Steven Earl Salmony (anonymous)

Making greed real............

Perhaps it is time for the same ol' business-as-usual, pin-stripe-suited leaders, the ones who adamantly espouse and religiously exemplify an apostate's creed of greed, to be replaced by new leadership.

Too many leaders of this patently unsustainable culture of avarice evidently define the culture's efficacy by the endless accumulation of material possessions; by the unbounded acquisition of more money, money, money, money; by recklessly overconsuming and relentlessly hoarding limited resources. They demonstrably declare to all the world that greed is good.

Are we not members of a culture that worships consumerism? Are the products of greed nothing more or less than the objects of our idolatry?

Are the pin-striped suits, fleet of cars, chauffeur, private jets, McMansions, distant hideaways, secret handshakes and exclusive clubs...... all "signatures" of success in a culture promoted by the 'goodness' of greed?

Consider for a moment what perversity greed has wrought.

Steven Earl Salmony
AWAREness Campaign on The Human Population,
established 2001
http://sustainabilityscience.org/content.html?contentid=1176

Written in December 2008

Charles M. 110°

First past the post voting very seldom delivers Green MPs so it is not surprising that Canada has none. It is very difficult for first past the post to deliver anything more than a two party government system.

Greens tend to fare far better in proportional representation governments at first as low % "fringe" parties but getting a higher % as their ideas get assimilated and they become more mainstream.

That's certainly the case in Finland, Germany and here in New Zealand.

New Zealand is interesting in that we have a mix of both proportional and first past the post. At first all the Greens were getting in via proportional, but now they are also getting in via first past the post as voters see them more as a viable choice than just as a bunch of tree-hugging nutjobs.

NZ has just been through an election and the Greens have increased their seats by 50%, but are still less than 10% of the house.

It has also been interesting to watch the NZ greens mature through this process. In the beginning they only had an environmental policy and no significant policies on other matters. Now that they are "growing up" and becoming more mainstream, the NZ Greens are producing interesting, and viable, policy in all matters.

Written in December 2008

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • (hint: logged in Celsias members don't have to fill in this)
  • Posted on Nov. 30, 2008. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Brian »

    2 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Promote Energy Security and Efficiency, 21°

    Draft energy policy to implement energy security and efficiency.

    Find (and lower) your carbon footprint, 209°

    Inevitably, in going about our daily lives, each of us contributes to the greenhouse gas ...

    Attend the 'Gore on energy and climate' event, 17 July, 32°

    On July 17, Vice President Gore will be issuing an unprecedented challenge to policymakers and ...

    Follow these related projects

    Rainforest Bullion

    Western Galilee, Israel

    Featured Companies & Orgs