Greek Solar Reactor Uses Nano-Material to Harvest Hydrogen from Water

John P.

oilWe've heard a lot recently about the problem of  "dependence on foreign oil." For some, "Drill! Drill! Drill!" has become their mantra in the American Presidential election, as hard-pressed consumers desperately hope for some relief from high fuel prices. The problem could be much better categorized though, as simply a "dependence on oil." This toxic liquid, which formed from rotting corpses and dead plant life over millions of years, is hard to find, even harder to get at, expensive to refine and transport and worst of all, it's contributing enormously to Global Warming.

What if there was an alternative though? What if the Earth was covered in lakes of an energy rich liquid that, with a bit of work, could solve our energy problems for good? Well, it might seem fanciful, but such a thing does exist. This liquid was formed billions of years ago. It's completely harmless to the environment and available everywhere. No, it's not some unheard-of rare mineral  I'm talking about, but simple water. Actually, the hydrogen in the water.

fire-waterEver since I started writing about possible solutions to Global Warming, friends have been sending me articles about new hydrogen cars or hydrogen fuel cells. The problem is that most of the hydrogen available today is produced using fossil fuels. So simply using hydrogen is not a solution to Global Warming. What's required is a means of producing hydrogen from water using renewable energy.

Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the Universe, but as elements go it's pretty promiscuous. It doesn't just sit around. It likes to interact with other elements, in particular oxygen to form water. Hydrogen is like a bad guest at a party. Once it gets into a water molecule it doesn't like to leave! It takes a lot of energy to get it out. Now a team of Greek researchers have found a way to extract hydrogen from water efficiently using sunlight.

The HydroSol project was started in 2002 with €1.33 million in funding provided by the European Union and a further €1.33 million contributed by a consortium of partners from Britain, Denmark, Greece and Germany. Headed by Athanassios Constantopoulos, Director of the Chemical Process Engineering Research Institute based in Thessaloniki, the Greek research team have constructed a reactor that is capable of splitting the molecular bonds that tie oxygen and hydrogen together to form water.

splitanim

honeycombThe solar reactor is comprised of a ceramic honeycomb of hundreds of channels coated with what the team calls a nano-material. The material is comprised of oxygen-deficient ferrite structures containing zinc and nickel. The reactor uses a two stage process. In the first stage the temperature of the honeycomb is increased as parabolic reflectors concentrate solar radiation onto its surface. At temperatures between 800 and 1,200 degrees Celsius the nano-material removes oxygen from water, producing hydrogen gas. In the second stage the temperature is increased further to between 1,000 and 1,200 degrees Celsius. As these temperatures are reached the oxidized nano-material is stripped of oxygen, producing oxygen gas. The nano-material is then ready to be used again.

Constantopoulos, who is, ironically, a specialist in catalytic converters for car engines, points out that the system has no moving parts. Water vapour flows in one side and hydrogen flows out the other. The channels provide a large surface area with which the water vapour can interact. Initial laboratory investigations showed that his solar reactor can convert water vapour to hydrogen and oxygen with nearly 70% efficiency using just sunlight. The laboratory based portion of the project was known as HydroSol I.

"The hydrogen produced can be channelled into a fuel cell to produce energy or to a combustion point. The hydrogen can also be stored, solving the problem of storing and transporting solar energy. Secondly, the reactor can be used to recycle carbon dioxide. The hydrogen, together with carbon dioxide, can produce new fuel (such as methane). So a reactor like this can be set up alongside units producing CO2. Thirdly, it can be used to desalinate water. It could be an integrated solution for the Greek islands, providing energy and drinking water just by using the sun and water".

hydrosol-spain-projectOn March 31 2008 the team held their first official demonstration of the solar reactor at Spain's Almeria Solar Platform. The successful demonstration marked the inauguration of HydroSol II. The next phase of the project, HydroSol III, will be a one megawatt power plant based on the technology. "Our dream is for HydroSol III to be made in Greece. The cost is not prohibitive, about €3 million," said Constantopoulos.

carIn 2006 the team was awarded the European Union's Descartes Prize for scientific research. For those who think that the movement from an oil based society to a hydrogen based society is in the distant future. Think again. Two hydrogen filling stations are already open to the public in Berlin. These stations produce hydrogen on site using electrolysis. However, soon we will be seeing many more of these stations around Europe, especially if good old Greek ingenuity has anything to say about it.

 

Further Reading:

11 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

C Robb W. 429°

Sounds promising. Hydrogen is a pretty poor energy carrier and due to the high amounts of energy needed to produce it, transport it and manufacture vessels to contain it, the energy return has been dubious. The filling stations that manufacture it on site solve one of the problems, transport, by avoiding custom pipelines. This Greek technology could be really positive if it can generate enough to offset it's embodied energy. Any idea what it takes to make manufacture this technology?

Written in October 2008

John P. 184°

Well the leader of the group says about €3 million for a one megawatt power plant. It seems the future will see us (in Europe anyway) moving more and more towards a hydrogen based economy as opposed to an oil based one.

I really like the idea of manufacturing hydrogen on site, but this technology requires sunlight, and we don't have a lot of that in the gaelic isles. Still a lot of economically deprived areas in the mediteranian could start producing energy for the rest of us and give their economies a boost.

Thanks for the comment Robb.

Written in October 2008

C Robb W. 429°

No problem John it's an intriguing technology and I appreciate
you bringing it to my attention.

I think you are right about needing loads of sun. Using Hydrogen to generate base load grid scale electricity would require loads of hydrogen and I'd be surprised if it turned out to be cost effective or efficient enough to compete with concentrated solar thermal electricity already online. Maybe if it was used to even out the troughs in combination with wind and solar it might find a niche.

I don't see the benefit of developing hydrogen as an energy carrier at the personal scale, as in a car, when we already have an energy carrier that is inexpensive, 96% recyclable, 100% chargeable via renewables. Batteries.

My cynical anti corporate self sees hydrogen as an attempt by big energy companies to maintain control of the flow of energy by storing it as a liquid which can be moved around, stored and commodified.

John, If Europe ends up moving to a Hydrogen economy I won't eat my hat but I'll buy you a beer. Shall we check back in around, say, 2020?

This technology looks interesting though and is worth keeping an eye on at the very least.

Here's another link about the technology
http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/story?id=38063

Written in October 2008

John P. 184°

Newcastle brown ale thanks.

Have you seen this?

http://www.celsias.com/article/nature-inspires-solar-power-revolution/

This sounds really exciting to me. The idea that we could all live off grid. Cool. What do you think?

Written in October 2008

C Robb W. 429°

I definitely think we should live off grid to whatever extent we can manage.

That technology you wrote about in the linked article is really the same sort of thing as the nanotech one. Essentially it is about making hydrogen cheaper, more efficient and more flexible in a variety of scenarios. It is exactly what I meant in my above comment about filling in the troughs, using hydrogen to solve the intermittency problem some renewables have.

It works the same as a battery, store the excess and use it later. I'm still doubtful about it's ability to be competitive with batteries. The production process looks relatively inexpensive but you are still faced with storage and fuel cells. Fuel cells are quite energy intensive to make and involve precious metals, they are also really expensive. If they manage to overcome all the cost challenges involved then maybe hydrogen could offer an alternative to battery storage at the personal scale.

I can get deep cycle batteries pretty cheaply and with proper system design and maintenance they can last up to 20 years. Spend less on the battery and you have to replace them more often. Reduce your demand more and you can buy less batteries. The point is I can get it now, build it myself and not break the bank.

That challenge, reducing demand, applies to either scenario however. Going off grid typically requires a commitment to demand reduction that many find difficult. Personally, I find it challenging but it's a challenge I enjoy. I also believe it is going to be necessary if we want to reduce our emissions enough to make a difference. The thing is, we can do it now. The technology exists, we don't need to wait for hydrogen.

Part of my problem with the whole hydrogen economy debate is that it plays into the school of thought that says we don't need big changes in our lifestyle, a new technology is just around the corner that will save us. As a result we keep on keeping on with our business as usual lives. As long as we are led to believe that and aren't informed that the technology to accomplish serious emissions reductions are here now, why change?

Written in October 2008

John P. 184°

All good points.

I'm particularly interested in your hydrogen economy view. Is it just another way to keep people dependant on big energy companies?

Could a home solution for using hydrogen to store renewably generated power be an effective tool against climate change?

I was interested in your point about batteries. Most poeple would see batteries as a dirty product, but fuel cells as clean (environmentally speaking). Is this really the case?

Written in October 2008

C Robb W. 429°

At the point hydrogen tech seems to be at now I don't see it becoming something individuals will be able to afford to go off grid with. Maybe someday. If it becomes affordable it offers promise as I think fuel cells can operate many more cycles of charge and discharge than current storage methods. They are also lighter than batteries though you would have to be able to store the fuel as well, so if it does become affordable at the household level it offers hope as a transport fuel. Also, there is the potential to have just one fuel cell, in your car, that can also power your home, this is true of battery technology as well. So an array of PV/wind/hydro would generate the hydrogen and store it in a tank, you would then use it in your car to run the fuel cell, when you are at home the car plugs into the house. perhaps acting as a backup battery charger for the home battery bank. There would losses in the conversion however so the efficiencies would have to be pretty high.

Batteries do seem like a bit of a chemical weapon but they are highly recyclable, about 96% of the lead is recovered in the EU and 90% of the electrolyte, largely due to EU regulations. And are quite safe if handled properly. It is a 100 year old industry, mature and relatively inexpensive. I'm unsure about the recycleability of fuel cells. Sounds like a good topic for research.

Yes, I believe the hydrogen hype is largely about promoting another energy carrier that can be commodified and controlled by big energy companies. Much of the recent development and promotion of hydrogen fuel cells came about through funding by the US military. They are looking for ways to avoid spending so much on transporting petro chemicals around. One of my early heroes, Amory Lovins at @ RMI who developed the hypercar (coincidence that it was at that stage hydrogen powered?), did some consulting for the Pentagon on ways to reduce dependence on fossil fuels. As usual the big boys have gotten in on the gravy train, GM being a prime example. Fortunately, I think many now see through the hype and the gloss has been rubbed off a bit. I believe it is still heavily funded research however. I have a tendency to believe that there is a way to make it work just because Amory Lovins says it can, he has such a sterling reputation, but I don't think it is there yet.

I see the way forward to be people taking responsibility for more of their own consumption through the production of what they need, food, clothing, transport, and energy, to whatever degree they can manage. We have the technology, today, on the shelves, you can buy it!

Written in October 2008

John P. 184°

Thanks again Robb for being so informative. I think their is a belief amongst governments that converting people into docile consumers will help keep their populations in line. Kind of like giving bread to the masses. Cheap available power seems to be a cornerstone of that philosophy. The recent economic collapse has helped to dispel that belief and with people like you getting the word out let's hope it's not long before we see a more educated and responsible society emerging.

Written in November 2008

C Robb W. 429°

One can only hope.

Written in November 2008

Paul (anonymous)

Nice read. Btw, the name of the director of CPERI is Athanasios Konstandopoulos (K instead of C).

Written in November 2008

omar (anonymous)

that very good

Written in April

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • (hint: logged in Celsias members don't have to fill in this)
  • Posted on Oct. 28, 2008. Listed in:

    See other articles written by John »

    11 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    We Need Clean Energy, Not Clean Coal!, 94°

    During the Vice Presidential debate, both Senator Biden and Governor Palin touting their support for ...

    Get Your Own Website with a Bright Green Web Host, 61°

    Your website, as an expression of your vision and passion, is the greatest shot you've ...

    Eat more vegetables, 1560°

    Dr Rajendra Pachauri, Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) says that if ...

    Follow these related projects

    What's Your Crazy Green Idea? Video Contest

    A X PRIZE Foundation project in Santa Monica, United States

    EnergySaint

    Cronton - a small village in Cheshire., United Kingdom

    Featured Companies & Orgs