The Economy: Changing Us for the Better?

Gina-Marie Cheeseman

purse Last fall, a shift began to occur in American society: Americans spent less and saved more. Retail sales fell 2.8 percent, the fourth straight monthly drop in October. At the same time the unemployment rate hit 6.5 percent. In a survey of 1,000 households, 43 percent were eating at home, 25 percent cut spending on hobbies and sports activities. The majority said they would continue when economy improves. The holiday season did not stop consumer spending from decreasing. In December, it decreased by one percent.

This year, Americans continue to spend less. The three-day spending average for February was $61, compared to last year's $140. The 14-day spending average in February was $59. Last year it was $98. Gallup's Consumer Mood Index decreased by four percent in March, and Gallup's Monitor of Consumer Spending was off by 27 percent compared to March 2008. 

Time magazine conducted research on how people are spending their money, and published the results during April. Sixty-one percent of those surveyed think they will continue spending less when the economy is better.

Learning to live sustainably?

As Americans spend less, they are learning to live in more sustainable ways. Many are growing their own food, and making their own household cleaners and laundry detergent. They are ditching bottled water for reusable water bottles, and disposable diapers for cloth diapers.

I asked my Facebook "friends" how they are coping with the recession. Someone responded that he buys "the needs not wants." Someone I grew up with told me she gardens, makes her own laundry detergent and soap, shops at salvage and thrift stores, buys in bulk, and barters with others. She even gave me a recipe for laundry detergent.

My friend is not the only one gardening these days. Many Americans are planting "victory gardens." First started during World War II to cope with food shortages, by 1943 there were 20 million victory gardens which reportedly produced eight million tons of food. First Lady, Michelle Obama planted an organic vegetable garden in March, the first such garden since former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt planted a victory garden.

The Obamas are in good company. Seven million more households plan to grow their own produce, a 19 percent increase, according to the National Gardening Association's survey. Last year it increased 10 percent.  

I recently read an Associated Press article about people who switched from disposable to cloth diapers. One woman said she was spending about $20 a week on disposable diapers until she switched to cloth. According to the market research firm, Mintel International Group Ltd. cloth diapers are a "fairly large" niche market that is estimated to be about $200 million annually.

Bottled water sales decreased by 10.4 percent during the first three months of this year, according to the Times magazine report. National Public Radio quoted Gary Hempill from the Beverage Marketing Corporation as saying,  "Anecdotally, we believe that consumers last year increasingly drank more tap water." Hempill attributed it to the economy.

Will it last?

When the economy is better will people go back to their super spending ways? No, they will not, according to Joachim Vosgerau, marketing professor at Carnegie Mellon University. "It seems like this trend is only going to continue."

A Business Week article characterized the spending shift as "quiet revolution in American culture." It could very well prove to be a permanent shift. Menzie D. Chin, economics professor at the University of Wisconsin, doesn't think consumers will be able to spend freely for another five years. By that time, Americans will have spent half a decade "channeling" their grandparents, to borrow the phrase from a Time magazine article.

Related features on Celsias:
10 Frugally Green Workout Tips

Disasters, Stuff, and What Is Enough?



Follow us on Twitter: Celsiastweets

4 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

William Martin (anonymous)

This is a great article, of how adversity can have such positive aspects. We cannot continue to ship our food thousands of miles and grow with toxic pesticides. Check out this video from Dr.Vandana Shiva on how a backyard food garden is the solution to many of our environmental issues...

www.tinyurl.com/growfood

When you are done, come visit us at www.onemilliongardens.com and participate in our free online gardening class and other great resources to grow more food than you ever dreamed possible...

See you in the garden!

Written in May

Charles M. 110°

It is interesting to compare the current downturn to previous events.

The Great Depression created a whole depression, many of whom lived very frugally for the rest of their lives. But then, this generation had no easy access to credit like our generation so it is very difficult to extrapolate from their actions.

WW2 brought on victory gardens etc which lasted the duration of the war, but soon waned after the end of the war.

9/11 brought a change in social values, but that didn't last very long.

The current recession might be bad compared to the last few decades, but it is nothing near as bad or deep as the Great Depression so it is unlikely many people will change long term.

Joachim Vosgerau notes that people are spending less, but that does not mean they are consuming significantly less. If they're buying store brands instead of boutique brands (or $10 wine instead of $35 wine) that does not really make a sustainability difference. They might be spending less on wine, but a $10 bottle of wine has similar environmental impact to a $35 bottle of wine.

In fact it is worse for some organic products etc. Organic is perceived as being expensive and extravagant and people feeling the pinch (or feeling guilty about spending) will often avoid the organic products even when they are the same, or very similar prices. This effect has lead to some suppliers even changing their packaging to remove the prominent "Organic" label and making it less visible. Even though they have not changed ingredients or prices they have seen an improvement in sales.

Written in May

Gina-Marie Cheeseman (anonymous)

Charles, you are right that the current economic crisis is not as bad as the Great Depression. However, it is bad...bad enough to scar the conscious of many people. The sheer amount of people who have lost their jobs and their homes is staggering. I am friends with a couple whose husband worked in construction. He has not worked since November. They now must rely on the wife's paycheck as their sole means of support. Their telephone is on its last leg and they can not afford a new one. Multiply them many times over and then tell me that people are not spending as much.

Come to my neck of the woods. I know many who are struggling just to put food on the table. Look at them in the eye and tell them one day they will take part again in conspicuous consumption.

Written in May

Gina-Marie Cheeseman (anonymous)

William, thanks for the info! I just bought plants and seeds for a summer garden. Free online gardening classes are a God send!!!!

Written in May

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • (hint: logged in Celsias members don't have to fill in this)
  • Posted on May 19, 2009. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Gina-Marie »

    4 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Crowdfund a Brew Hostel, 11°

    When you've got a Sustainable Cohousing Network, Crowdfunding a Brew Hostel is the logical next ...

    Get Your Own Website with a Bright Green Web Host, 61°

    Your website, as an expression of your vision and passion, is the greatest shot you've ...

    Switch from paper to continuous cloth towels for the office , 21°

    Paper towels are more expensive and more harmful to the environment than cabinet towels (aka ...

    Follow these related projects

    Featured Companies & Orgs