Ecological Voyeurism

JoDee Powers

When I see sidelines on the covers of my favorite outdoor magazines like “Top Ten Places to See Before They Vanish”, it sends chills up my spine.  It leaves me pondering questions like “Just how many top ten places have already vanished?  Is anyone keeping track?  What top ten are next in line?  If they are so great, so valuable, so worth seeing, why are they vanishing and why would we let them?   

Once they’re gone, will we ever be able to replace the beauty, wildness and sacredness that have been destroyed?  What kind of mindset do we have that makes something man-made more important than the beauty of places yet untouched, but scheduled for demolition?  It reminds me of a carnival barker, “Get your tickets here folks.  See the rare and beautiful Arctic Tundra before it melts.  Exclusive tickets, just step right up and see it before it’s too late.  Only a lucky few (and probably wealthy) will have this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.   Don’t miss your chance.  See it now”.   

wilkins As my stream of consciousness about this continues, I wonder how long it will be before there are no more “Top Ten” places for us to see before they have vanished?  Currently it seems that Antarctica is at the top of the list of things to see these days. There are a range of tourist opportunities to “experience” the beauty of a polar ice cap before it completely vanishes. 

You can take a cruise along ice peninsulas, helicopter rides for ice reconnaissance, shore visits with scientific experts, dog sled adventures, etc.  Within myself I sense that there is something inherently wrong with this mentality and way of perceiving our world.  We’re anxious to get a first hand glimpse of our own demise.  So much so that we are actually willing to pay for it! 

Your browser may not support display of this image.The truth is we are completely unable to integrate that watching a polar ice shelf the size of Rhode Island break off into the ocean and melt away forever, (though probably an awesome and spectacular sight), is like cutting off the tip of our earthly pinky finger.  Little by little we are whittling down and cutting away all things that sustain us as a living organism on this planet. 

We’re killing ourselves and other species at an unprecedented rate and strangely, we want to have front row seats at this event.  It’s like driving by a car accident. We have to slow down and look.    We are actually willing to pay to watch Rome burn.  We’ll enjoy good food, have an adventure, take photos and return home, providing slideshows to our friends so that they can live this demise vicariously through us.   

I think I’ll coin this “Ecological Voyeurism”.  A sort of sick fascination with watching the planet in its death throws.   We find it exciting.  In some ways an “exclusive” experience that few get to see, making those of us that did experience it, unique, perhaps special.   And in the end, when we are old and a grandchild sits on our lap, we can describe this to them in detail.  “You should have seen it honey, it was truly grand. I’m so sorry that this beauty isn’t around for you to see and experience for yourself.  But I was lucky, I got to see it before it was gone and I can at least show you the photos and tell you about it”.   

Hmmm.  How special is that?

More cool stuff on Celsias:

The State of Antarctica's Ice

Requiem for a Crowded Planet

Follow us on Twitter!

3 comments

If you see any unhelpful comments, please let us know immediately.

fred (anonymous)

As the sun continues to slumber, the ocean cools and the polar icecaps grow as time goes on it becomes more and more evident that global warming is simply a money making scam that ignores the environment and does almost nothing to help it.

www.twawki.com

Written in April 2010

Shaer (anonymous)

Did you know that MBT shoes is the first physiological footwear, and that it has a positive effect on the whole body.
Your should ruduce cellulite, tighten buttocks, tones butt muscles, tone legs improve posture, flsttens stomach and so on when you wearing a MBT sneakers. http://www.bootsue.com

Written in May 2010

plant (anonymous)

I agree with you about such headlines as "The Top 10 Places to Visit Before they Vanish!" But what about the fact that visiting is *making* them vanish? Those cruises and helicopter trips to Antarctica waste precious fossil fuels, whose burning is melting the polar ice caps. As are road trips to scenic places, to environmental conferences, and "no war for oil" rallies. Good grief people, we need to drive as little as we can in over the course of our lifetimes, and over the course of each week. Write down your weekly mileage every Friday night, to the nearest tenth of a mile (or smaller increment), and over time, weekly mileage will decline of it's own accord. The average American driver drives a whopping 230 miles per week. If just one in 10 of America's 200 million drivers each drove 3 miles less per week, it would be an enormous help. It would save 2.7 million miles of driving per week, or 65,000 barrels of crude oil weekly, or 3.4 million barrels of oil per year.
Thanks for your post.

I found your article while searching for a wonderful environmental essay written in the 1970s, I believe, about American car tourists "consuming" landscapes by driving through and ruining them en route to scenic destinations for the purpose of landscape voyeurism.
It would help if more people seeking to enjoy nature, instead of taking a long drive and a short walk, would take a short drive, and a long walk.

Written in November 2010

Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • Posted on April 27, 2010. Listed in:

    See other articles written by JoDee »

    3 comments


    Pledge to do these related actions

    Attend the 'Gore on energy and climate' event, 17 July, 32°

    On July 17, Vice President Gore will be issuing an unprecedented challenge to policymakers and ...

    Food for Change: eat only plant-based foods for one whole MONTH, 112°

    Ok, now this might seem really hard for someone who has not done this before. ...

    SOS: Small Islands States, 52°

    Dear friends, Next week, desperate due to accelerating sea level rise, a group of small ...

    Follow these related projects

    The Economics of Happiness conference

    Berkeley, California, United States

    Featured Companies & Orgs