Biofuels - It's Getting Annoying Now

Life is a big learning curve, isn't it? From the moment we're born, till the day we die, we're constantly faced with decisions and predicaments - of varying degrees of importance - the choices we make normally determined by the information we've previously assimilated, and that have shaped our perspective.

Amongst ourselves, as families, societies, and nations, we have different perspectives, and therefore make conflicting decisions. But, we learn to live, or try to live, with these decision-making conflicts. We all grow and learn. With patience, a touch of objectivity and a little humility, we come to examine various controversies from previously unseen angles, and our choices improve. We share information, and counsel, we discuss - and, hopefully, we listen.

Sometimes, however, we can be tempted to make decisions that go contrary to the contextual framework the choice is centred in - in other words, contrary to what we know is right, contrary to the evidence. We get caught up in a tide of interests that go beyond what is 'wise', or 'expedient', or 'practical'. This is the point where the tools of patience, objectivity and humility become useless - because the decision is no longer based on a shortage of information, or a willingness to do the right thing. This is the point where counsel and discussion gives way to bitter controversy, and ultimately, war. This latter scenario, I'm tempted to say, seems to be the case in regards to the obstinate pushing of ethanol from corn, sugar, soy, and palm oils in the face of their overwhelming detrimental effect on people's lives, and on the environment. It is where big industry, desperate to retain consumer dollars, is influencing government - who are in turn pandering to very destructive whims.
Accordingly, I'm determined to place resources on this particular post, which will grow over time, as you contribute, drawing a clear line between the effects of biofuels on people and planet, and what government and industry are doing regardless. You are welcome to contact me to suggest additional information for the list below.


Enough Already
The Facts

-Biofuels, from the Frying Pan into the Fire
-Biofuel Nightmares - Indonesian Palm Plantations
-As Corn Ethanol Threatens, Algae Makes Promises
-Water Shortages Exacerbated by Biofuels
-Ethanol Anger as Bush Arrives in Brazil
-Lula da Silva Speaks
-The Coming Biofuels Disaster
-Ethanol Slaves
-Biofuels Impacting on Charity Food Operations

-An Agricultural Crime Against Humanity
-Ethanol Fueling Amazon Fires?
-A Lethal Solution
-Worse than Fossil Fuel
-Feeding Cars, Not People

Washington Post:
-Corn Can't Solve Our Problem
-The False Hope of Biofuels

Earth Policy Institute:
-Massive Diversion Of U.S. Grain To Fuel Cars Is Raising World Food Prices
-Exploding U.S. Grain Demand for Automotive Fuel Threatens World Food Security and Political Stability
-Supermarkets and Service Stations Now Competing for Grain
-Biofuel Blunder - Briefing before U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works

Institute of Science in Society:
-The New Biofuel Republics

World Rainforest Movement:
-A clear message from the South: We Want Food Sovereignty, Not Biofuels
- Biofuels: A Serious Threat, Masked in Green
-NGOs warn Africa on the dangers of biofuels and genetic engineering in the fight against Climate Change

Tom Paine:
-Burdening Brazil with Biofuels

New Scientist:
-Forests paying the price for biofuels

-What About the Land?
-A Bridge to Somewhere?

Associated Press:
-Scientists weigh downside of palm oil

-Sustainable Monoculture? No, thanks!

New Statesmen:
-Frankenstein Fuels

Energy Bulletin:
-The Ethics of Biofuels

Portland Independent Media Center:
-Biofuel and Genocide

-EU fuel push 'may damage forests'
-Biofuel demand makes food expensive
-Europe biofuel plans under fire

Goldman Sachs:
-Rising Biofuel Use to Drive Up Crop Prices

Earth Meanders:
-Clean Coal, Forest Biofuel and Other Fairy Tales

-Ethanol's corn-fed boom holds hidden costs: higher food prices

East Anglia Food Link:
-Food production: land, population and water

Salt Lake Tribune:
-Crop prices soar, push food costs up globally

Yahoo News:
-Ethanol boom could worsen world hunger: study

Culture Change:
-Peak Soil: Why cellulosic ethanol, biofuels are unsustainable and a threat to America

-The Great Biofuel Hoax

Determined Obstinacy
We will drive, come hell or high water

George Bush:
-U.S. auto industry presses Bush on biofuels
-U.S. and Brazil Sign Biofuels Cooperation Accord

-Join Brazil in planting oil
- Biofuels Republic Brazil
-Soya is not the solution to climate change
-Brazil - Renewable Energy Example to the World or Time-bomb for the Amazon?
-Greenpeace Protest Greets Lula-Bush Biofuels Meeting in Sao Paulo

Arnold Schwarzenegger:
-Schwarzenegger Directs State Agencies on Biofuel Use
-EU proposes 'blunt' transport biofuel target as Schwarzenegger shows the way forward
-Next Schwarzenegger target: fuel emissions
-Gov. Schwarzenegger issues biofuels executive order

European Union:
-230 say 'no' to EU's biofuels directive
-EU makes bold climate and renewables commitment
-'EU biofuel-use targets must be abandoned'

United Kingdom:
-Biofuel plant 'could be anti-green'
-Renewable Transport Fuel Obligation (RTFO) feasibility report

-Mexicans stage tortilla protest
-Tequila, pork and orangutans: new victims of the biofuel boom

-Chinese Biofuels Expansion Threatens Ecological Disaster
-China seeks boost from biofuels
-Biofuels eat into China's food stocks

Indonesia & Malaysia:
-Indonesia's Biofuel Expansion on Rainforest Peatlands to Accelerate Climate Change
-Energy Companies Rethink Palm Oil as Biofuel


As George Monbiot just wrote:

"It used to be a matter of good intentions gone awry. Now it is plain fraud. The governments using biofuel to tackle global warming know that it causes more harm than good. But they plough on regardless." - Monbiot

It's getting annoying now. We'd like to make politicians painfully aware that we're not fooled by the greenwash. We are onto you. And before people pipe up with the 'cellulosic ethanol', and 'algae' arguments - fantastic, yes, keep the research flowing. But, in the meantime, in the interim, let's not spend the next ten or more years flattening our forests, hastening habitat destruction, the demise of soil fertility, and increasing the pressure on the world's poor just so that rich consumers in the North can continue their lifestyles of excess (without any discernible change in comfort levels), and so that an oppressive minority in the South - a 'lucky few' - can endeavour to attain the same. A potential future breakthrough in alternate technologies is no excuse to continue present destruction and systematically apply misery to the lives of untold millions who have no voice.

I wholeheartedly endorse George Monbiot's suggested freeze of all governmental subsidies and legislation that are encouraging destructive biofuel production:

We need a moratorium on all targets and incentives for biofuels, until a second generation of fuels can be produced for less than it costs to make fuel from palm oil or sugarcane. - Monbiot

Should governments encourage growing food for vehicles?
Not Sure

Again, this should only speed the development of truly sustainable fuels.

A moratorium on the European Biofuel Directive and similar policies does not mean that all support for biofuels should be suspended. There is a strong case for government and business investment into lingo-cellulosic technology, biodiesel gasification [update: see Elmuth Ernsting's comment] and algae research, all of which could vastly increase the amount of truly sustainable biofuels available to us. This should include funding of life-cycle studies which look at greenhouse gas emissions, land-use changes, impacts on biodiversity and on food supplies linked to those new technologies. Those studies should then be used as a basis to determine research priorities. - From the 'Biofuel Paper' (900kb PDF) produced by Biofuel Watch.

What can you do? Get involved in Biofuel Watch's campaign here, send a link to this Celsias page to your local political representative, pump your tyres up, drive less, and sensibly - and, if possible, get rid of your vehicle entirely.




Add a comment
  • to get your picture next to your comment (not a member yet?).
  • Posted on March 28, 2007. Listed in:

    See other articles written by Craig »

    Pledge to do this related action

    Build an information web site about Electric Vehicles with Zero Emissions, 16°

    Build an information web site about Electric Vehicles with Zero Emissions. Provide this information so ...

    Follow these related projects

    Energy Economy Real Facts

    On Line, United States

    Featured Companies & Orgs